I also used the black eyeliner pencil to tightline and put on the waterline. If you wanted to add black eyeliner for the top lash line, I do not recommend using the pencil in this palette. I tried it on the other eye and it pulls and does not apply well.
I do like the highlight color in this as it's more of a satin finish, for those who do not like a shimmery highlight
(On the face, Chanel Vitalumiere Aqua, Eve Pearl Salmon Concealer)