After seeing a lot of reviews on youtube, I finally picked up two lip creams by Nyx from Ulta during the 40% off Nyx sale. These normally retail for $5.99 and come in 11 shades. I most wanted Antwerp, but it was sold out, so I chose Stockholm (a darker nude shade - on left) and Istanbul (bluish pink).
Repurchase? I would repurchase it if it were on sale again, but I don't wear mattes enough to justify full price as I was constantly topping it with a gloss. I also had to touch up more throughout the day b/c it does tend to wear more off the inside of the lips.
Grade (1-5): 3 for all day wear, 4 for the colors they came out with and the packaging.